El Siboney Restaraunt - On Catherine St. South of Truman Ave. in Key West, FL
I dream nightly of going back to The Keys and eating at places like this again. The food was delicious and the place was clean and reasonably priced. I slowly savored every single bite. The place was very busy, probably because it's a great place. This meant that, while the servers weren't rude, they seemed to have no time for pleasantries. Honestly, it didn't bother me, as long as the food, prices, and cleanliness hit the mark, which they did. I highly recommend this place.